Bryan Roberts: Clubcard and Nectar won’t lure Aldi and Lidl shoppers

Tesco Clubcard 2017

Perhaps overshadowed by the exits of Dave Lewis and John Rogers, the big reveal of supercharged loyalty schemes from Tesco and Sainsbury’s did not receive the amount of fanfare that the retailers had been anticipating.

Although they have taken markedly different directions of travel with Clubcard and Nectar respectively, one senses that both retailers had identified a degree of disenchantment among their shoppers concerning loyalty cards.

Indeed, both businesses have diluted the benefits of the points accrued through their respective cards over the last couple of years and shoppers have not been shy in terms of expressing some dissatisfaction.

Antipathy is by no means limited to Nectar or Clubcard, in particular. TCC Global research shows that a typical UK shopper owns five loyalty cards but uses just three. Around 70% of shoppers want to be rewarded for their loyalty by more than just a loyalty card. And only 6% of shoppers would stop shopping with a retailer if their loyalty card scheme was scrapped. In short, small plastic rectangles are no longer cutting the loyalty mustard.

Subscription content

Please sign in now if you have a subscription or are already registered with us.

Retail Week

Register for free to continue reading provides premium, in-depth intelligence that helps retailers judge risks, spot opportunities and identify what they need to do to win in the digital economy.

Register today for a taste of our high-quality intelligence and enjoy:

  • Two free article views per calendar month on
  • Detailed analysis of current trends and events 
  • Exclusive newsletters
  • In-depth reports, videos, interviews and much more

Discover Retail Week register now

Please note, if you have recently purchased a subscription, it may take a few minutes before your account is updated.