Analysis: Is the CMA killing retail?

Ripped up handshake

Asda-Sainsbury’s, JD Sports-Footasylum and potentially Amazon-Deliveroo – the CMA has been taking a tough stance on retail M&A over the past two years. But is the watchdog’s clampdown on mergers actually hurting the industry?

It is supposed to be the government department scrutinising merger and acquisition activity and holding businesses to account on behalf of consumers.

But, over the past two years, the tables have turned – the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) is increasingly coming under the microscope.

A combination of blocked deals and a swathe of phase-two investigations since last spring, in particular, have stoked concerns.

Last April, the watchdog blocked the £13bn mega-merger between Sainsbury’s and Asda over fears the combination would lead to “increased prices, reduced quality and choice of products, or a poorer shopping experience” for shoppers.

In October, the CMA cited similar reservations when launching an in-depth phase-two probe into JD Sports’ planned £90m acquisition of rival Footasylum – something JD Sports boss Peter Cowgill fervently dismissed.

Just last week it made an eleventh-hour intervention into online food delivery specialist Just Eat’s £6bn merger with Dutch rival and received a defiant rebuttal from Amazon and Deliveroo over its probe into their proposed tie-up.

Subscription content

Please sign in now if you have a subscription or are already registered with us.

Retail Week

Register for free to continue reading provides premium, in-depth intelligence that helps retailers judge risks, spot opportunities and identify what they need to do to win in the digital economy.

Register today for a taste of our high-quality intelligence and enjoy:

  • Two free article views per calendar month on
  • Detailed analysis of current trends and events 
  • Exclusive newsletters
  • In-depth reports, videos, interviews and much more

Discover Retail Week register now

Please note, if you have recently purchased a subscription, it may take a few minutes before your account is updated.